We got some split-slate MLB DFS action on this Thursday. Because it’s the middle of the damn afternoon already, I’m obviously only breaking down the 5-game main slate, which is surprisingly large for a Thursday. Hallelujah for that.
Haven’t tried our MLB DFS Builder yet? Not sure what you’re waiting for, if not. We also now support MLB DFS Showdown for DraftKings as of today, and we’re adding new bells & whistles all the time. More sports are on the way, as well. For now, get yourself a 7-day free trial and test it for yourself. We’ve gotten excellent results so far, and it’s only going to get better and better.
In the meantime, let’s Do The Stuff.
MLB DFS Pitcher Picks for Thursday
- Chris Sale ($10,500, vs. TOR)
- Shota Imanaga ($8,500, vs. ATH)
- Justin Wrobleski ($8,200, at AZ)
- Seth Lugo ($7,900, at MIN)
- Jared Jones ($7,500, at HOU)
- Kai-Wei Teng ($6,500, vs. PIT)
- Ryne Nelson ($6,200, vs. LAD)
Not the most awe-inspiring group of pitchers, but hey, it’s a 5-gamer. We’ll start with Chris Sale, the obvious Ace Of The Slate at home against Toronto. Sale is sporting a tight 2.01 ERA, a 2.91 SIERA, and a 3.19 xERA. The strikeouts (30.2%) are still there. The low walks (6.4%) are still there. The groundballs (44.1%) are better than they were last year. Sale’s 115 Stuff+ and 14.1% swinging strikes rank among the MLB leaders. On a tiny slate, Sale will be extremely chalky. Based on the numbers, it’s justified.
The case against him is he’s the most expensive pitcher on the slate and he’s going to get a boatload of ownership. The Jays have also hit for decent power (.175 ISO) against lefties, while they’re not striking out much at all (17.2%). On another slate, maybe I’d let the field chase him in a spot that isn’t a great one to hunt for ceiling. Sale will probably be the highest-scoring pitcher, but remember, ALTPLS.
Shota Imanaga is the next-most-expensive pitcher, at a whopping $2,000 discount from Sale. Imanaga has pitched pretty well for most of the season (24.3% Ks, 6.3% walks), but he’s also a flyball pitcher allowing plenty of power, and the wind is blowing out at Wrigley tonight. On the bright side, the A’s lineup tonight is striking out a ton against southpaws (25.3%). I think Imanaga is likely to hover in the 25% Ks range, so there’s certainly upside if he can generate some swings-and-misses. There’s also obvious downside given the context here.
But, hey, Imanaga is $8,500 on a small slate. Boom/bust pitcher in a boom/bust matchup. Playing the A’s is certainly viable.
I’m not sure what to think of Justin Wrobleski. After posting a strikeout rate of over 27% last year, he’s been deliberately pitching to more contact this season. His 2.87 ERA looks nice, but not trying to miss bats is an inherently more volatile style, as you’re relying on those batted balls to find gloves. I do think that 27% K-rate was probably lucky given the 10% SwStr% he posted, but I also know there’s more in the tank here than his 2026 16% K-rate indicates. In his last start – on the heels of a rough outing against Milwaukee – Wrobo went out there and struck out 9 Phillies across 7 dominant innings. The Dodgers have consistently given him a long leash, as well.
I don’t know which version of Wrobo we’ll see tonight, but, based on the matchup, we probably won’t see the 9-K version again, as the DBax are one of the lowest-strikeout lineups in the league (14.6%) against lefties. They’ve also hit for some power (.201 ISO). I suppose Wrobleski is playable in large-field, but I’d rather get onto the Arizona side of this.
Seth Lugo always has a wide range of outcomes. His 4.24 SIERA is a lot weaker than his 3.55 ERA, while the groundball stuff he showed earlier in his career has apparently evaporated. Lugo’s 20.1% K-rate and 7.7% walk rate are both average, as is his matchup on the road in Minnesota. Lugo’s 87 Stuff+ this season is also the worst of his career, and he’s 36. Seems like he’s kinda washed, though this Twins lineup (.153 ISO) is largely bereft of thunder. I suppose Lugo will crack my player pool, but I won’t be getting much of this.
Jared Jones burst onto the scene a couple of years ago, missed all of 2025, and now he’s back for his 2nd MLB start of the season on the road in Houston. Jones is a high-velo prospect who racked up a decent number of Ks (26.2%) in his first turn at the MLB level, and he struck out 6 Twins on 77 pitches in his season debut last week. I think he’s going to be very good – and he may be very good already – and he’s only $7,500. We’re probably looking at 85-90 pitches here in a so-so matchup against the Astros. The Astros’ power is almost entirely concentrated at the very top of the lineup, and there are some high-K bats scattered throughout. I’m on board, though I assume the field will be, too.
Kai-Wei Teng gets the ball for the Astros on the opposite side. His 25.7% K-rate on the season is solid, though the 11.4% walk rate is #cause #for #pause. He’s gotten lucky with both BABIP and stranding runners, which helps to explain the gulf between his 2.57 ERA and 3.83 SIERA. I think he’s a pretty good pitcher, though he has had some trouble getting blasted by lefties. The Pirates have a pretty good offense these days, and their lefties happen to be their most menacing bats. Pittsburgh has also been quite patient (11.4% walks) with average Ks. I think $6,500 for Teng is totally fair, and he’s another boom/bust option who makes the cut on a slate without a ton to like on the pitching side.
Ryne Nelson gets the Dodgers, which will be enough to keep his ownership in check despite his cheap $6,200 price point. Nelson’s 4.64 SIERA ain’t great, and he’s suddenly morphed into an extreme flyball pitcher this season. His strikeout rate is down about 3% from last year to just 18.7%, albeit with still-excellent control. Nelson’s Stuff+ and SwStr% are almost identical to last year’s. He appears to have fully abandoned what was a mediocre change-up and replaced it with a sinker. Unfortunately, the sinker is also mediocre. On the bright side, he’s not throwing it a ton. The Dodgers are the Dodgers, so it’s probably the worst matchup on the slate. I do think Nelson is a decent enough pitcher, though, and if he’s lower-owned than Teng, I’m fine with clenching my bootyhole and making that pivot.
SP Rankings
- Sale
- Jones
- Imanaga
- Nelson
- Teng
- Lugo
- Wrobleski
Top MLB DFS Stacks (6/4)
- Cubs (vs. JT Ginn)
- A’s (at Shota Imanaga)
- Pirates (at Kai-Wei Teng)
- Twins (vs. Seth Lugo)
- Braves (vs. TOR bullpen?)
- Royals (at opener/Mike Paredes)
- Dodgers (at Ryne Nelson)
- DBax (vs. Justin Wrobleski)
- Astros (vs. Jared Jones)
The only team I didn’t list here was the Blue Jays against Sale. There’s your clearest path to leverage on the slate, though it’s also an extremely low-percentage stack. I don’t hate mini-stacking or one-offing with guys like Springer, Guerrero Jr., and Okamoto, but, ya know.
I’m guessing the Cubs will be The Chalk at home against JT Ginn with that hitter-friendly wind at their backs. Ginn isn’t bad, but he is a very splitsy right-hander, albeit with some groundball skills. If he can keep it on the ground, the wind won’t matter. The Cubs have some lefties hitting the ball hard and in the air against RHBs, namely Pete Crow-Armstrong, Michael Busch, Ian Happ, and Moises Ballesteros. I can’t really poke holes in these guys, other than ownership. Everyone’s playing Chris Sale and pairing him with the Cubs, so it’s up to you to either Not Do That or to Do It, But Differently. Including a righty or two – Alex Bregman? Nico Hoerner? Seiya Suzuki? – is one path.
The A’s have a 4.6 implied run total of their own, so let’s not overlook them. They’re also not projecting for a ton of ownership. I kinda think they’ll be fairly popular Because Wind, but Imanaga will also get some attention by default. While RHBs have the best long-term numbers against the lefty, he has yielded a lot of power this year (.227 ISO, 13.7% barrels) to same-handed bats. That’ll keep everyone in play. Shea Langeliers, Colby Thomas, and Brent Rooker are the RHBs likely to get the most attention from the field, but Nick Kurtz (9.3%) and Tyler Soderstrom (12.5%) are still barreling up left-handers. I like it.
I guess we should talk about the Braves. Mason Fluharty will open for Toronto, and there’s no telling what they’ll do after that. Toronto did acquire Simeon Woods Richardson yesterday, so there’s some speculation that he’ll be the bulk guy for the Jays. SWR hasn’t been in town for long enough for the Blue Jays to potentially fix him, so I assume he will remain terrible if he does get into this game. The issue is we just don’t know yet, as of this writing. I’m not a fan of stacking against bullpens, but Atlanta does have a healthy 4.7 run total. Ronald Acuna Jr., Matt Olson, Ozzie Albies, Michael Harris, and Austin Riley are your headliners in stacks, as always.
Both teams in PIT-HOU have neutral 4.2 totals. I mentioned Teng’s issues with lefties, and we like the Pirates’ lefties – Oneil Cruz, Brandon Lowe, Ryan O’Hearn, Bryan Reynolds, Spencer Horwitz. Endy Rodriguez and Jake Mangum will also swing it from the left side, for whatever it’s worth. By playing the Astros you’re looking to leverage Jones’ likely ownership, which is a fine strategy. Yordan Alvarez, Christian Walker, and Cam Smith are the only Houston bats with double-digit barrel rates vs. RHP, though I don’t mind getting to Isaac Paredes, Jeremy Pena, or Taylor Trammell, either. Probably rather play HOU in large-field.
I don’t know who Mike Paredes is, but, apparently, he’ll come in after the Twins use an opener. Even he probably won’t last very long, so it’s probably a true bullpen game. It looks like the Royals will be kinda chalky, though I’m not entirely sure why. Bobby Witt Jr., Carter Jensen, Vinnie Pasquantino, and Salvador Perez are probably the ones you want, while they do have a ton of cheap bats elsewhere in the order. The field is very confident the Royals will have a ton of success here. I am not that confident, but they’re fine, I guess.
Seth Lugo seems to kinda stink these days, so the Twins aren’t a bad alternative, especially since both teams have 4.5 totals in this one. Byron Buxton, yes please, while I’m otherwise looking to get to Brooks Lee, Kody Clemens, Josh Bell, etc. The issue is this team also kinda stinks these days, so it’s an Old Fashioned Kinda Stink-Off.
Ryne Nelson is really giving it up to LHBs, so fire up the usual Dodger lefties – Ohtani, Muncy, Freeman, Tucker, Rushing.
I’ll side with the Arizona RHBs against the lefty, Wrobleski – Marte, Arenado, Moreno, Waldschmidt. Corbin Carroll, always good.
Stack Confidence-o-Meter
- Cubs
- A’s
- Braves
- Pirates
- DBax
- Dodgers
- Twins
- Astros
- Royals
- Blue Jays

Noah Simpson is a New England-based DFS writer who has spent the better part of a decade obsessing over MLB DFS. He got his start playing DFS recreationally before realizing he was spending more time building spreadsheets than actually watching games, and decided to make it official. At DFSBuild, Noah covers MLB DFS strategy with a focus on finding edges that casual players overlook. When he’s not staring at Statcast data, he’s somewhere on a hiking trail in Maine with his two dogs, Sandboy and Johnner, who are undefeated at ignoring his lineup advice, because they are dogs. They don’t have the cognitive or motor skills required to operate a computer, let alone process complex theories and information.






Leave a Reply