It’s important to start every 2026 fantasy football draft on the right foot. I’m sure you’ve heard the old saying “you can’t miss on your first pick”, and it’s not just an expression. Whiffing on a pick that challenges the league for most points is a big deal, especially since a good chunk of your opponents are probably going to hit on theirs.
Whether that first-round pick gets hurt, you reach, or they just fail to deliver, this isn’t the spot of your fantasy draft where you can afford to miss the mark. Due to that, it’s crucial to nail this pick from every possible angle. To do that, I’ve inspected your best options from every single draft spot, and I’m pointing you to who I’d pick at that slot, and which options you should consider (and avoid).
With that, here’s the best fantasy football picks from every spot in the first round of 2026 drafts:
Note: This breakdown uses full PPR, 12-man leagues with 1QB as a baseline.
Pick 1.01: Bijan, Gibbs, Ja’Marr, or Puka
These are the only fantasy picks I’d be considering at the #1 spot. This is where you look at the top of your fantasy football rankings and make sure you don’t go too far down the list. Your league settings could differ, so if you’re looking at half PPR or standard scoring, I’d lean into one of the running backs.
Detroit has been pretty loud about making Jahmyr Gibbs into a true “bell cow”, so if I have to take a stand in the Bijan vs. Gibbs fantasy debate, I am leaning toward the Lions rusher. That said, Bijan’s 2026 fantasy outlook is amazing.
I don’t think the gap is that wide, and if we’re talking full PPR, both of those guys are still firmly in play. You can also turn to Puka, who was sensational last year as the WR1 overall despite missing a game.
Davante Adams is due for some touchdown regression and some of that could go Puka’s way. That puts him in the #1 pick crosshairs, but you can only have one guy here. In full PPR formats, Ja’Marr Chase is the guy I want.
Puka took the WR crown last year and Christian McCaffrey was the top overall fantasy player. I don’t think C-Mac repeats that, however, and I think Chase is the better pick over Nacua. Why? Because Chase had to deal with Joe Burrow missing nine games and he still finished as WR4 overall.
Chase had little consistency in his favor last year and scored nine fewer times than he did in 2024, when he was the WR1 overall. If he and Burrow can stay healthy, he’s a terrific bet to take his crown back.
Pick 1.02-1.04 – Rinse & Repeat
Again, what type of league you play in matters, so be sure to take note of your league size, roster settings, and how your league scores points. But short of something super weird, you’re probably looking at one of the other three dudes in the previously discussed four-pack.
My pick for the #1 slot in 2026 fantasy football drafts is Chase, but I’ll agree with you that it probably isn’t by much. We’re splitting hairs here, but once again in full PPR I’m perfectly content going with Puka and then going to Gibbs and Bijan.
There really are no wrong answers here. If the league is half PPR or standard, I’d pivot away from Nacua and take Gibbs first. And you just work through those guys and take the best one depending, on which slot is yours among 1.02, 1.03, and 1.04.
The moral of the story? They’re all awesome and about as close to can’t-miss as it gets. The sad songs start playing once you get outside of the top four fantasy picks in round one.
Pick 1.05-1.09 – The Sun God & More
A very strong case can be made to take the plunge for Christian McCaffrey here, while other stud wide receivers like JSN, Justin Jefferson, and CeeDee Lamb also exist.
I think there’s a case for and against everyone here, except Amon-Ra St. Brown. And by that I mean the case for him is very strong, but the case against him is non-existent.
The Sun God may not be quite on Puka or Ja’Marr’s level in terms of ceiling, but he’s not that far off and he’s been absurdly consistent. Old Reliable is still just 26 years old and his role in an awesome offense is going nowhere.
Here’s what he’s been up to the last four seasons:
- 2025: WR3
- 2024: WR3
- 2023: WR3
- 2022: WR7
To be fair, this is overall and not points per game, but St. Brown wasn’t a punk in that regard in 2025, as he averaged 19.1 fantasy points per game – good for WR4. In terms of upside, consistency, and foundational structure (no major change), I think he’s the best pick at 1.05.
I don’t want to drown you in my personal takes too much, so you can still pivot to any of these other guys. We know Lamb and Jefferson have top-5 upside, and C-Mac has an amazing role that powered him to legitimately the top overall fantasy score a year ago.
But C-Mac is also 30, made of glass, and coming off a 400+ touch season. Jefferson was not able to overcome quarterback issues in 2025 and may face that obstacle yet again. Lamb’s upside has clearly been curbed to a degree by the presence of George Pickens. And JSN, as amazing as he was, could be due for at least some slight regression now that OC Klint Kubiak is in Vegas.
All of these guys are in play, but the first to go should be St. Brown.
1.10-1.12 – Brock Bowers & More
I am a big fan of picking late in drafts. Not because I don’t want the opportunity to get Ja’Marr, Gibbs, or whoever else up top, but because I love the ability to nab two studs B2B.
Getting someone like Chase, Gibbs, or Bijan is obviously great, but then I have to wait forever to go get my second guy. It can force my hand a bit in terms of how I want to construct my roster. At the turn, I know I’m getting two studs and I can build exactly how I want to from that spot.
The mentality is the same, whether I am at the 1.10, 1.11, or 1.12. In that range, we can definitely look to guys like Jonathan Taylor, Christian McCaffrey, and Ashton Jeanty. But the first pick in this range that’s on my radar is easily Brock Bowers.
Bowers could be gone by now in TEP formats, but even in regular PPR leagues, he is an awesome way to get the party started. We already know Bowers has TE1 overall upside, and the crazy thing is he’s never had an ideal situation.
Last year he wasn’t even at full strength and he was still one of the best fantasy tight ends in the league. In 2026 he’ll be fully healthy, he should have a quarterback upgrade, and he has former Seahawks OC Klint Kubiak in town to run the Las Vegas offense.
Kubiak featured JSN in Seattle and I fully expect him to go out of his way to do the same with Bowers, who is a total matchup nightmare. Not only are you getting a potential TE1 overall here, but you can win the tight end matchup almost every single week.
After getting Bowers, you can circle back and get a stud RB that I already mentioned, or nab a wide receiver like Drake London with your next pick.
Making the Best Picks in Round One in Fantasy Drafts
The first round is where fantasy football leagues are often won or lost. While it can be tempting to chase upside or reach for your favorite player, the best drafters focus on minimizing risk while securing elite production.
Target players with proven workloads, stable roles, and high weekly ceilings. Volume remains king in fantasy football, especially in Round 1. Running backs who dominate touches and wide receivers who command massive target shares should generally be prioritized over players relying on efficiency or uncertain situations.
Just as importantly, avoid overreacting to offseason hype. Every year, managers talk themselves into risky picks based on training camp reports, coaching changes, or small-sample breakouts. Round 1 is not the place to get cute.
Build your foundation with players who offer both a high floor and league-winning upside. The goal isn’t to win the draft in the first round. It’s to avoid losing it.
Playing DFS since the days of DraftStreet, Kevin knows the ins and outs of DFS, specifically for NFL and NBA. He’s also been helping people win in fantasy football leagues for 15+ years and is one of many experts featured at FantasyPros.
Want more winning DFS plays like this? Get our daily core plays, leverage spots, and strategy sent straight to your inbox.
Leave a Reply