Hello! It’s Thursday, which means there are just a handful of MLB games on the schedule, but MLB DFS is better in every way than showdown NFL DFS, so maybe you’re playing baseball instead. I assume the contests are trash because Football Reigns Supreme, but I suppose there’s still money to be won in the baseball streets.
Should be a quickie today, so I suppose we should rock and/or roll.
MLB DFS Pitchers for Thursday
- Taj Bradley ($9,500, at Angels)
- Sonny Gray ($9,000, at Rangers)
- Nolan McLean ($8,700, vs. Phillies)
- Walbert Urena ($8,500, vs. Twins)
- Aaron Nola ($7,500, at Mets)
- Framber Valdez ($6,800, at White Sox)
- Ethan Pecko ($5,500, vs. Royals)
This is not the most ace-laden slate we’ve ever had. Many people are saying there are no aces at all, in fact. The closest thing is Taj Bradley, I guess, who gets a nice draw on the road in Anaheim. We play against the Angels and their 25.6% K-rate vs. RHP every night, seems like. Bradley (27.3%) has good strikeout stuff himself, and most of his troubles have come against lefties. As we’ve mentioned a million times, the Angels have exactly zero lefties you’re scared to play against. The Halos do have some patient bats, and Bradley’s walk rate north of 10% on the season could lead to some #issues, but I also think he’s the only pitcher on the slate capable of putting up a score you absolutely cannot win without.
Sonny Gray has bounced back in a big way after a slow start to ’26. He’s up to 26.6% strikeouts over the last month along with almost no walks. He is allowing some power (.188 ISO, 10.5% barrels) to lefties, and the Rangers do have a few decent lefties populating the order. It’s also just naturally not as strong of a lineup overall vs. right-handed pitching, especially on the strikeouts front (23.1%). Globe Life Depot is also quite pitcher-friendly, so I’m in on Gray at $9,000. If you wanna pair the $9,000 guys and call it a day, you’ll probably do just fine.
Nolan McLean may be a full-time ace one day, but for now, he’s just an occasional ace. A 26.4% strikeout rate for the season puts him in Bradley’s neighborhood, but the Phillies are a more potent, less strikeout-prone offense than the Angels are, of course. I do like that McLean’s strikeout stuff is consistent against hitters from both sides, though, and $8,700 isn’t a particularly cumbersome salary. I’d rank him behind Bradley and Gray in terms of priority, but he’s still pretty high on the wish list here.
Walbert Urena continues to pitch very well for the Angels, though he’s much more of a groundballer (55.1%) than striker-outer (22.5%). He has flashed more K ability vs. RHBs, though the Twins are only projected to have 4 righties in the order tonight. It’s not the scariest group, especially now that the Twins have reached the stage of the season where the bottom-half of the lineup is largely comprised of minor-league create-a-players you encounter 30 years into your video game dynasty. I should also note the Twins’ 3.75 total in this game is tied with the Angels for the lowest on the slate. I’ll rank Urena slightly ahead of McLean, thanks in part to the $200 discount you get with Walby.
Aaron Nola is a pretty average source of strikeouts at this stage of his career, and he just won’t stop allowin’ dingers. The Mets can stack the lineup with lefties, which also suboptimal. $7,500 is a decent price point for Nola, but the top group is strong enough that he’s not a guy I’m playing much.
Framber Valdez has had a frustrating first season in Detroit. His 17% strikeout rate is extremely weak, though he’s still keeping the ball on the ground nearly 56% of the time without allowing a ton of power. As always, it comes down to whether the dreaded and feared BABIP Gawds will choose to smile down upon Frambito. The White Sox (.207 ISO, .353 wOBA) have been potent with the bats against LHP, but they’ve also been pretty strikeout-prone (23.2%). Most importantly, Valdez is just $6,800. We’ll see some ownership here, but I think most will just choose to spend up at both SP spots. I think Framber’s solid enough for the slate.
It sounds like the Astros will open again with Miguel Ullola before Ethan Pecko enters in bulk duty against the Royals. Not one, not four, but TWO rookies. I’m seein’ double here! Pecko hasn’t pitched much at the MLB level, but he looks extremely splitsy so far, with terrific numbers against righties and nothing at all good against lefties. Kansas City can get pretty lefty-heavy here, and they’re not a great matchup for Ks. The thing is Pecko is probably a pretty decent pitcher, and he’s only $5,500. Not sure you need to be full punting, and I think Valdez is just a much safer option for only $1,300 extra, but reckoned I’d mention him, mostly just to force in the Simpsons reference.
SP Rankings
- Taj
- Gray
- Walby
- McLean
- Frambito
- Pecko
- Nola
Best MLB DFS Stacks for Thursday
- Astros (vs. Seth Lugo)
- Mets (vs. Aaron Nola)
- Phillies (at Nolan McLean)
- Tigers (at Erick Fedde)
- Royals (at Ethan Pecko)
- Red Sox (at Cody Bradford)
I’m guessing the Astros and Tigers will be trendy bats tonight against Seth Lugo and Erick Fedde, respectively. Lugo hasn’t pitched well at all this season. The strikeout stuff is A Thing Of The Past, while LHBs (.246 ISO, .452 wOBA) have really slapped his face around over the last month, in particular. APYA, while Daulton Varsho and LaMonte Wade Jr. will hold the platoon edge here along with Yordan. Not the most thrilling stack of lefties, but I’m not worried about Lugo’s numbers vs. RHBs enough to fade Jeremy Pena, Yainer Diaz, and Isaac Paredes. Diaz (.417 wOBA, .208 ISO) is really raking over the last month, as well.
Fedde’s probably the worst starter on the slate. RHBs have done more damage against him for the season, but his K-rate against lefties is hovering down around 11% over the past 30 days. Detroit chalk is the definition of unexciting, but Kevin McGonigle, Riley Greene, Dillon Dingler, Colt Keith, and Spencer Torkelson have hit the ball hard vs. RHP all season. Max Clark and “John Peck” are pretty cheap.
Let’s see…what else do we have. The Rangers are apparently opening with Tyler Alexander before Cody Bradford comes into the game. I’m not sure what the point of opening with a lefty before bringing in another lefty is, but, apparently, that’s the plan. I’m seein’ double! Two lefties!
Willson Contreras is back, and he’s crushed lefties all season. Jahmai Jones and Wilyer Abreu also have double-digit barrel rates, while Adley Rutschman and Trevor Story have good longer-term track records.
I’m guessing the Mets will find some ownership thanks to the matchup against the power-prone Nola. Franciscos Lindor and Alvarez, Juan Soto, and Brett Baty have the best barrel rates among Mets vs. RHP, while Carson Benge has come on strong later in the season. It’s the Mets, but I don’t see much not to like here.
I feel similarly about the Phillies, who are probably the most talented offense on this slate, yet the matchup against McLean and his goatee means we’ll get them at fairly limited ownership. Lefties have decent numbers against the righty for the season. Great news for Bryce Harper and Kyle Schwarber, while Luis Arraez, Bryston Stott, Brandon Marsh, and Justin “Carl Jr.” Crawford will all hit lefty, as well. It sure seems like Brandon Marsh morphed back into Brandon Marsh after turning into Bryce Harper in the first half, so that’s concerning. Trea Turner and JT Realmuto are solid values at $4,100 and $2,900, respectively. This is probably my favorite stack on the slate.
I mentioned Pecko’s Trouble With Lefties. Carter Jensen, Jac Caglianone, Vinnie Pasquantino, Michael Massey, and Isaaac Collins, come on down.
Stack Rankings
- Phillies
- Mets
- Tigers
- Astros
- Royals
- Red Sox

Noah Simpson is a New England-based DFS writer who has spent the better part of a decade obsessing over MLB DFS. He got his start playing DFS recreationally before realizing he was spending more time building spreadsheets than actually watching games, and decided to make it official. At DFSBuild, Noah covers MLB DFS strategy with a focus on finding edges that casual players overlook. When he’s not staring at Statcast data, he’s somewhere on a hiking trail in Maine with his two dogs, Sandboy and Johnner, who are undefeated at ignoring his lineup advice, because they are dogs. They don’t have the cognitive or motor skills required to operate a computer, let alone process complex theories and information.






Leave a Reply